• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to Alfonso's Pizza & Pasta

Alfonso's Pizza & Pasta, located in Port St. Lucie, FL, offers a delightful culinary experience for Italian food enthusiasts. Renowned for its homemade sauce and fresh dough, the menu features an array of pizzas, including a mouthwatering Meat Pizza and classic Cheese Pizza, alongside hearty appetizers like Garlic Knots and Fried Ravioli. Customers rave about the rich flavors and generous portions, with many highlighting the classic Sicilian-style offerings. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, Alfonso's stands out as a must-visit destination for pizza lovers craving authentic Italian flavors. Their affordable prices make it a true gem in the community.

LOCATIONS
  • Alfonso's Pizza & Pasta
    2740 Brigantine Pl, Port St. Lucie, FL 34953, United States
    2740 Brigantine Pl, Port St. Lucie, FL 34953, United States Hotline: +1 772-878-0042

Welcome to Alfonso's Pizza & Pasta, a hidden gem nestled in Port St. Lucie, Florida. Located at 2740 Brigantine Pl, this local favorite has garnered a loyal following for its mouthwatering pizzas, delectable pasta, and inviting atmosphere. With a simple yet cozy interior, Alfonso’s may not catch your eye from the outside, but once you step in, the aroma of freshly baked pizzas and hearty Italian dishes will undoubtedly draw you in.

What sets Alfonso's apart is its commitment to quality. Each pizza is handcrafted with dough made from scratch, giving it a distinct, warm character that resonates with customers. The Sicilian style thick-crust pizza is a standout — rich, robust, and perfect for sharing. One satisfied customer, Nicole Rivera, raves about the Sicilian pizza with pepperoni and bacon, calling it "so good" after a long search for quality in the area. With its indulgent arrangements and classic flavors, it's easy to see why Alfonso's garners such praise.

For those craving variety, the menu offers unique options like the Chicken Parmigiana Pizza, which combines juicy chicken with marinara and melted cheese for an uplifting twist on tradition. Or try the Fresh Tomato Pizza— a delightful composition of garlic, fresh tomatoes, cheese, and oregano that speaks to the simpler, yet profound pleasures of Italian cuisine. Customers consistently applaud Alfonso's pizza quality, noting rich flavors and generous toppings, as highlighted by Brandon Anderson's enthusiastic feedback.

And it’s not just the pizzas that steal the show. Dive into their selection of pasta dishes like the Stuffed Shells or the hearty Baked Ziti. Each bite is a testament to homemade culinary craftsmanship, bringing the warmth of family traditions to your table. The Hot Subs, such as the mouthwatering Chicken Parmigiana Sub, showcase harmonious flavors, making them worthy additions to your order.

Alfonso’s isn't just a pizzeria; it's a testament to the love for food and a place where every dish is crafted with care. As Steve Krasco recounted, even a simple meatball parm sub can be "absolutely fantastic," proving that quality and taste are at the heart of everything they serve. The reasonable prices and friendly service only enhance the overall experience, making it a go-to for many, including families and pizza aficionados alike.

If you're looking to indulge in a slice of Italian heaven or feed a crowd with exceptional pasta, make your way to Alfonso's Pizza & Pasta. Trust me—you won't just leave full but also satisfied and eager to return. Welcome to a celebration of classic flavors—where every dish feels like a warm embrace!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Alfonso's Pizza & Pasta
Nicole Rivera
Nicole Rivera

We got the Sicilian with pepperoni and bacon. Omg! So good. Is it’s been awhile since I had good Sicilian style pizza. The “Roni garlic knots” are delicious too. Will order again.

Brandon Anderson
Brandon Anderson

My opinion..... Italian food, especially pizza, would be my final meal. From either Little Italy in Saranac Lake or Rustica in Fajardo, Puerto Rico. But... Alfonso's was pretty darn good. We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and an order of mild chicken wings. I love my wings crispy, so they definitely get a high 8 out of 10. The pizza on an all-time scale of 1 to 10, which I use for everything... movies, women, etc. I give the pizza a 7.5 with an overall rating of 8. I've been to a few other pizza places in PSL and haven't returned to any of them a second time. Alfonso, I see you soon!!

Steve Krasco
Steve Krasco

I had been shopping at Bass Pro with my 2 year old and asked if she wanted pizza for lunch. I did a quick Google search and found Alfonso's. From the outside it's unremarkable and the inside is simple. I had a meatball parm sub which was absolutely fantastic and my daughter had a slice. The pizza was very good also. I wish we lived closer, I would make this my go-to pizza place. Also the prices were very reasonable and the staff was friendly.

Kylie R
Kylie R

this place is bomb!!! we always get a regular cheese pizza every time and it’s amazing every time. we also like to try a new side sometimes and this time we tried the garlic knots with pepperoni. 10 out of 10. so garlicky and delicious.

Gloe Jassie
Gloe Jassie

This is the only phenomenal pizza place I can find in this area, I had a Large Pepperoni pizza on 5/21/25 and It was just the best thing ever! I really mean that. The feeling you get with a mouth full of real cheese, Pepperoni, and real dough and ingredients. Due to the popularity of this place, expect wait times. They make their own pizza sauce and dough from scratch. This is not a "franchise' The dough is so good, if you have kids, don't throw the crusts away. Dip them in some melted butter.

Claudia Solano
Claudia Solano

I just can tell one of the best pizza from the area, they are so kind and friendly. I been eating this pizza since a moved to Port Saint Lucie from NYC. I 100% recommend it.

J C
J C

I ordered two pizzas, one with sausage and meatballs and another with bacon and pepperoni. Great taste!

Honey Badger
Honey Badger

Chef's Salad was AWESOME. And the Chicken Parm with Penne was Delicious. And Who doesn't like Garlic Knots?! Really Hit the Spot. Highly Recommend.